SocialVibe.comThe Vibe
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

While, everyone goes through rough patches in high school, they’re much rougher for some. Many, if not most, LGBT students face severe discrimination on school campuses. Is creating separate, LGBT-oriented schools the answer or just a band-aid that postpones real solutions?

san_fran_rainbow_flag

Consider the case of Tarrell Hogle. One of just a few openly gay teens at his high school in Wisconsin, he was routinely bullied and often cut class on days that he just couldn’t take the harassment. Absences got him suspended and his schoolwork and grades suffered. Halfway through 9th grade, he transferred to The Alliance School in Milwaukee and now excels in his classes.

    “It’s hard to pay attention when other people are taking your things and trying to provoke you.”

Tarrell’s experience throughout the first half of his freshman year was not unusual; a survey by the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network (GLSEN) revealed that a whopping 61% of LGBT students feel unsafe at school. Nine out of ten have been verbally harassed and nearly half have experienced physical harassment by prejudiced classmates.

According to The Trevor Project, the leading US organization focused on crisis and suicide prevention efforts among lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning (LGBTQ) youth, LGBTQ teens are 4 times more likely to attempt suicide than their peers.

Despite the current problems, Rick Garcia of the LGBT advocacy group, Equality Illinois, says that by separating the students, other schools could be less likely to address the problem on their campuses.

    "If we create ‘Homo High,’ we don’t have to prohibit this behavior in other schools. The reality is, we have to live as neighbors. We have to learn to tolerate one another, if not accept one another. All our kids should be safe in all our schools; segregation is not the answer."

What do you think? Share your thoughts in the comments.

[poll id="201"]


20 Comments   
: ?>
Bookmark and Share

Related Posts:




COMMENTS (20)
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Solun

Solun says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

There should be LGBT specialized schools but everyone should try to be in "normal" school before trying special school.

Bby Doll

Bby Doll says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

What People Have To Realize Is This Is 2010 Gay People Are EVERYWHERE. But If Things Haven't Changed By Now, Do You Really Thing They Are Going To Change Anything Soon. I Mean Hell Black People Are Still Discriminated Against After 50+ Years. Discrimination Is Nothing New To The World, Its Been Around for Years And All Ways Will. People Are Close Minded And Set In Their Ways. Is Segregation The Answer, Probably Not But Tolerance Is Not Something That's Going To Easily Learned So Till Then I Believe That LGBT As Well As Others Who Face Severe Discrimination On School Campuses Should Have Somewhere To Go Where They Feel Save. That's Just My Opinion.

Ednerz

Ednerz says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

i dont think itd be helping anyone.
i was openly gay. and sure i never got messed with face to face. but if we segregate it wont help. people have to learn to be more accepting or learn to accept they cant do anything to stop others from being themselves. Segregation for orientation? not cool.

Lavish

Lavish says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

It's dangerous, I think, to have a sort of segregation like this. It won't stop the harassment, but instead, create more misunderstanding amongst students because now, if they're not gay, they might believe that there's something wrong with those who are, and that's why they need to be sent to this other type of school. The kids who are homosexual will think that they cannot be around the straight kids...they'll feel a bit alienated, and those who want to stay in their schools will be one in only a few to no gay student body.

And putting members of a certain group all into one building is never a great idea either. Something might happen because of a spiteful straight (or even gay) who really dislikes the homosexual community.

And even in sports, you can't say their won't be teens saying, "Oh, we lost to those gay freaks" or "We need to win at whatever cost because they don't like us" versus the normal, "The kids at that school are total jerks, we've gotta win".

Segregation is a bad idea. Teach tolerance.

I see little good in setting up these schools.

Natsuo

Natsuo says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I think schools need to teach more about it. I'm always nervous to say anything about sexuality in school or do projects about it, cuz it feels like it's taboo. I don't like the idea of segregation. Even though I'm a lesbian, I wouldn't go to a school that was just for LGBT. If people are being bullied, then the teachers need to do something about it, not stand there and pretend they don't notice. Where I live, I haven't seen many people get bullied for being gay, but I know it's out there. There needs to be presentations and speakers in schools about this type of thing to raise awareness. It's 2010, it's time for change.

Sweet Couture

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

This is sick, creating "special" schools for queers. Please, give me a break.

oh cara maria

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

As an openly bisexual female with a girlfriend, I feel really safe at my highschool. I feel like it's each schools fault if they don't keep their students safe, or make more punishments and rrules against any type of harrassment, anti-LGBT or not. Separate schools is ridiculous. That's what a GSA (Gay Straight Alliance) Club is for in highschools and Colleges. It's for LGBT(Q) students to gather and feel safe together. But its not like in the real world we're going to have.. oh say.. The straight Verizon Wireless store and the LGBT verizon wireless store. Why separate us at the most crucial developmental period of our lives, our teen years, when in a few months after we graduate we're going to be thrown into a world where people don't care what we are, we're all going to be in the same place? We should be learning to take on the challenge of a bully or a mean peer, and seeking mental help if we need it, not cowering in a corner amongst others of our "kind". There's protecting children and then their's catering to them, like being LGBT is some kind of handicap.

crazyykiddnallely!

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I am partly for and partly against. I believe everybody should accept on another for who we are not for what gender we love. They need to understand that because I'm "straight" does not mean I'm going to look at you differently if your not. I think that if it becomes too difficult for an individual, then yes, the need for segregation is there. Don't let the teasing and bullying go too far.

xspideyxlovesxallx

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

i have so much i could say on this issue but what it really comes down to is one thing: love is love. no one should ever be discriminated against for who they love or the way they lead their lives. every single person was created to be exactly who they are. no one should be able to determine what "normal" or "right" is. Lesbians, Gays, Bisexuals and Transexual people are PEOPLE. they have hearts and feelings and bleed the same color as every other person on the planet. no one should be hated for who they are<3

MandiCandi

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

what i don't get is why people discriminate in the first place. Sure, its not exceptable in most religions, but God loves all people. And no one has the right to judge another because of their sexuality. People should learn to accept others and segragating LGBT students is not going to help people accept them.

MonksPoint

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

We do need to teach tolerance. But if attending a LGBT school isn't made mandatory by the prejudice people out there and are instead a choice for people, then I'm for them.

bianca

bianca says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I think it's good that they exist and people know that if they can't possibly go to a normal school there's a second option, but they should try normal schools first.
if we separate them, people are going to think that gay people (or even black, for that matter) are an anomaly and will treat them as such.
so, if you can stand a normal school, stay there!

Zackaroni

Zackaroni says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I'm totally for the schools. There are many openly LGBT students at my school, and we all still get harassment from people who don't get it.

Richard Lee

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I believe sexuality is the same thing as freedom of speech, which should not be limited or discriminated for.

jaleen73

jaleen73 says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

It don't matter if some1 is white, black, or gay or watever! every1 should treat ppl the way they would want to be treated, it don't matter if u like the person or not!

BjaneF

BjaneF says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

i hate the idea its just bad all around. they cant just get lgbt jobss soo its bad. school is suppossed to help u 4 the REALLL world duh.

JWC+AER

JWC+AER says:
POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

I'm kind of for it and kind of against it.. My freshman year of high school was hell.. I missed SO many days of school and my grades suffered for it because of harrasment EVERY day, ALL of the time. But it's wrong to be like.. Well you're gay - let's put you in a gay school.

Casey Chromatic

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

people just need to cut the crap and treat eachother with respect. there is no need to tease anyone for anything. i dont care what anyone says, WORDS kill people all the time

CourtneyThompson

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

that's a stupid idea. everyone is going to get 'bullied' even if your straight. its just a matter of how you handle it. taking LBGT kids out of a regular highschool would be no different than seperating the white&black students. or any other race for that matter.

baileyboo12

POSTED 1 YEAR AGO

this is a tough desicion. if we were to have an LGBT school it would promote segregation, which causes tons of problems and US can't afford another segregation idea. we really need people to realize that they need a level of tolerance in life, and harrassment causes suicide. wasn't the US supposedly "the country for all sorts and variety"? i thought that would mean pexceptance, but apparently not. but the LGBTQ discrimination needs to be fixed. the school would only be a temorary solution. we need a program that can go to schools, go completely public, and help cease discrimination and harrassment. we need to wake up our society and give it a good kick in the ass;)


  1. On World Refugee Day, Help Put an End to Genocide
  2. What Would it Cost to End World Hunger?
  3. Saudi Woman Arrested for DWF (Driving While Female)
  4. Elephants Never Forget
  5. Clean & Declutter to Help Charity
  6. Great News: TV is Good for You
  7. 3 Minutes of Fun Facts about Presidents
  8. Blind Faith: Atheists Know the Most About Religion
  9. When Recycling Kills
  10. New Study: Racism is bad for Your Health

The Latina Diaries: Can a Latina be a Vegan?

POSTED 15 DAYS AGO
 
[...] photo source [...]
 

Not Mice « CollTales

POSTED 1 MONTH AGO
 
[...] our stomach is full of red flags about it. That’s because before some Russians started training cats to behave more like dogs for a...
 

Givfe

POSTED 1 MONTH AGO
 
Givfe says:
This is why i picked this cause, there are people out there who are dying..
 

19 months from launch to $1,000,000,000 acquisition: Instagram « Rational Idealist

POSTED 1 MONTH AGO
 
[...] but that on it’s own is not worth 1/30th of world hunger. [...]
 

grandpabear

POSTED 1 MONTH AGO
 
If you are so hot; why the heck is there nothing going on here for months and years at a time???